| The last five
years have seen an explosion of property websites offering literally thousands
of properties in all parts of France. The sheer weight of numbers can be
confusing and the problem is compounded by the fact that French vendors
tend to list their property with more than one agent.
An agent or
notaire offering a property for sale must hold a 'mandate of sale'
from the owner/vendor. The mandate will specify the sale price of the property,
the percentage and amount of the agent's commission, and the amount the
vendor will receive after deduction of the agent's commission (known
as the prix net vendeur). The property is then advertised at the sale
price stated in the mandate. An agent cannot suddenly decide to offer the
property at a higher price than stated in the mandate, because he encounters
someone he thinks is a gullible foreign buyer! This is a fairly common
myth which needs to be countered. The mandate can be either exclusive,
or alternatively the vendor may decide to instruct a number of agencies,
and also reserve the right to conclude a private deal. However if the vendor
tries to conclude a private sale with a client who has been introduced
by the agency, under French law the agent can sue for his commission (as
he has fulfilled his part of the contract with the vendor to find and present
a willing buyer of his property). This is why when being shown a property
by an agent you may be asked to sign a bon de visite (acknowledgement
of visit) which shows that you were introduced by the agent.
Some vendors
are in the habit of signing mandates with more than one agency, in the
hope of a faster sale or a better price. This means that the same property
can be featured in several estate agent's shop windows or in advertising,
sometimes at different prices. This is because agents can broadly set their
own rates of commission, which may vary from one agency to another.
Another potentially
frustrating consequence of multiple mandates is that, in the competition
to sell, some agents may not immediately inform their colleagues when a
property is sold or under offer through another agent. They may indeed
not even know which other agents have a mandate and of course the vendor
may have also reserved the right to sell privately and bypass all the agents
if he receives a good offer through his own efforts. This can be frustrating
for potential buyers who may be taken to see the same property by different
agents; and when you make an offer, it can sometimes be difficult for your
agent to find out if the property has actually been sold or not. Vendors
can be elusive when you need to contact them urgently, and in one recent
(and fortunately rare) case involving a married couple in the throes
of a divorce and unable to agree, he said Yes, she said No (or vice-versa),
until in frustration my clients pulled out of the deal and bought something
else!
Buyers can
sometimes not understand why a property they liked and were told had been
sold can sometimes reappear on the market at a later date. This can be
yet another consequence of multiple mandates described above, or simply
that potential buyers change their mind – maybe they cannot raise
the necessary finance or they take advantage of the seven-day cooling-off
period and pull out of the deal. So the property comes back onto the market.
Many of these
complications can be avoided by using a specialist adviser to help with
your property search and negotiation, ideally someone with fluent French
and an understanding of the law. It is also useful to understand the different
stages in the buying process and what protection you have if you decide
to change your mind.
The buying
process
There are
three main stages in the buying process which are described below. They
are the Offer, the Compromis de Vente or pre-contract, and the Acte Finale
or final contract.
If you see
a property that you wish to buy, the first step is to make a written offer.
This can be either at or below the asking price for the property. The offer
should state whether you are intending to pay cash or are seeking a bank
loan or mortgage. In the latter case, the amount involved and the name
of the bank or financial institution are included in the offer document.
This is usually a standard form provided by the estate agent.
The estate
agent handling the sale will contact the vendor with your offer. If the
vendor accepts, he will be asked to sign a written confirmation. The property
is then withdrawn from the market. If the vendor refuses your offer and
you do not wish to make a higher offer, the matter ends there. If you wish
to make a higher offer, the preceding steps are repeated until agreement
is reached, or your final offer is rejected and the transaction lapses.
Note that a
vendor is normally obliged to accept an offer at the full sale price. This
means that if he is presented with two offers simultaneously, one of which
is at the full price, then the vendor is obliged to accept this offer.
The sale price is the price at which the property is offered for sale by
the agent, who by law must hold a written mandate from the vendor to negotiate
the sale of the property. You cannot be gazumped by someone offering more
than the stated sale price.
At this stage
you will normally be asked to transfer a deposit (usually 10 per cent
of the sale price) to the agent’s special sequestered account
- provided that the agent is authorised and insured to receive such funds
(a sign in the agent's office will mention the maximum sum involved
and the name of insurer). If this is not the case, the deposit will
be sent to the notaire appointed to handle the transaction. The buyer is
also asked to supply his/her personal details (name, address, marriage
date etc) required for preparation of the compromis de vente.
The compromis
de vente or pre-contract is then prepared by the appointed notaire (sometimes
by the agency handling the transaction). This document sets out the
terms under which the transaction will be completed. If the purchase is
subject to the buyer obtaining a loan or mortgage, this is again stated
in the compromis as additional time is allowed to the buyer to secure the
necessary funds (not less than 30 days). You are obliged to report
progress on your loan application during this period, otherwise you can
be at risk of losing any deposit paid.
Other 'suspensive
clauses' may be written into the compromis, with the agreement of the
vendor, such as 'subject to satisfactory survey' and again the buyer
must demonstrate due diligence in organising a survey of the property.
Note however that a clause stating that the purchase is 'subject to the
buyer selling another property' would not normally be acceptable to the
vendor as the element of uncertainty means that the transaction could be
delayed for weeks or even months due to the vagaries of the property market.
The compromis
de vente is sent by registered mail to the buyer's home address (even
if it is has already been signed by the buyer in the agent's or notaire's
office). This is because, under French consumer protection law, the
buyer is allowed a seven day 'cooling off' period at this stage. If as
a buyer you wish to exercise this option, you must notify the agent and/or
notaire within the seven-day period of their intention not to proceed with
the purchase. If a deposit has been paid, it will be refunded.
If the buyer
does not wish to exercise this option (to withdraw within seven days)
the transaction will proceed, taking about two months to completion and
signature of the acte finale (described below). Note that the vendor
does not have a seven day cooling off period.
The acte finale
or final sales act will be prepared by the notaire appointed to handle
the transaction. As part of the process, the notaire will conduct the usual
searches (title, no right of pre-emption by the State, no outstanding
mortgage or charge on the property etc) and the obligatory expertises
will be undertaken. These are expert surveys to check the property for
lead, asbestos, termites, state of gas and electrical installation, and
to certify the dimensions in the case of properties situated within a condominium
(such as apartments), as well as matters such as the copropriété
(building management) agreement. An expert will also prepare a report
on the thermal efficiency of the property in line with recent legislation.
Some areas of France are also subject to risks from flooding and there
are regulations defining the minimum level of new residential buildings
above the ground.
Should any
problems be encountered at this stage, the notaire will contact buyer and
seller, and it may well be that the sale lapses at this point or some kind
of agreement is arrived at between the parties. However, reputable agents
will normally have made a number of checks before taking a property onto
their books, and most sales proceed smoothly to completion and signature
of the acte finale.
A few days
ahead of the signature of the acte finale the notaire will contact the
buyer advising him/her of the amount of the final payment to be transferred
to his special sequestered account (ie. purchase price – deposit
paid + transaction fees and costs). These funds must be in the notaire's
account at the time of signing the acte finale.
Buyer and seller
attend at the notaire's office for the final signature, though either or
both can give a power of attorney (procuration) to the notaire if
they do not wish to attend in person. This must be arranged beforehand.
At the signature, keys are handed over to the buyer who takes possession
of the property at this point. The buyer also becomes responsible for insuring
the property, and paying utilities, taxes etc. The agent normally notifies
the utility companies of the change of ownership.
The notaire
will give the buyer an attestation confirming that he/she is now the owner
of the property as it takes some months before the title deeds are received.
Some 4 to 6 months after completion, the notaire will send the new owner
a copy of the title deeds (titre de propriété) together
with his final itemised account and possibly a small refund of any fees/costs
overpaid.
Costs and
taxes
Buying a French
property involves some extra costs in addition to the purchase price. They
include transaction costs - commonly referred to as notaire's fees - which
are on a fixed scale, and add between 7 - 8 per cent to the cost of buying
the property. They include the notaire’s emoluments (about
30 per cent) plus government taxes and filing/land registration fees
(about 70 per cent). However, unless otherwise stated, agency fees
are included in the sale price of the property and are paid by the vendor
out of the proceeds of the sale.
The notaire
will normally charge an additional fee for extra work such as preparing
a power of attorney, and advising and preparing the documentation needed
for special purchase arrangements, such as creating a property holding
company (for example, an SCI), unmarried or same-sex partnerships
etc or advising on French succession laws or a change of marriage regime,
if required. These are best discussed in advance of preparing any documentation.
It is customary
to use a single notaire to handle the transaction and act for both parties.
The notaire is an independent professional as well as a semi-public official
whose role is to ensure that government taxes (such as capital gains)
are correctly paid over, and that the transaction is legal and transparent,
and fair to both parties. You should seek independent professional advice
on such matters as taxation, inheritance issues etc particularly where
these are subject to specific laws in your own country or in France.
The principle
property taxes in France are local authority and central government property
tax (taxe habitation, taxe foncière) details of which should
be included in the agent’s property description where known.
They may not be precisely calculated in the case, for example, of a newly
built property or a property that has been converted or renovated, until
the French tax authorities have received full information on the property
and can set the appropriate rate.
Capital gains
tax is payable on the sale of second homes in France, at a fixed rate during
the first five years, with tapered relief applying from years 6 to 15,
after which no CGT is payable. CGT is not payable on sale of your main
or principal home and this will normally be the case for those who move
to France with the intention of staying and making it their principal place
of residence.
The author
Peter-Danton de Rouffignac is an Englishman of French descent. After working
for nearly thirty years as a consultant and university lecturer in London,
he moved to France's Mediterranean coast in December 2001. He now works
in the property business as an advisor and consultant, helping non-French
buyers wanting to live and work in France. He has a degree in HRM from
Coventry University and a degree in law from the University of Warwick.
He is the author of more than 20 business books and reports. www.francemediterraneanproperty.com |