Is
There Trouble In Paradise?
In
New Zealand ~ by Candy Green
|
|
...
| “I’m
taking your brother and going to the South Pacific!” my dad would occasionally
threaten when frustrated by raising two temperamental daughters.
During the
Depression, young, and without clear direction, he had done a stint with
the Army in Panama. Then, he enlisted in the Navy. When War II began, he
found himself on a destroyer, the USS Nashville (CL-43), headed for the
Solomon Islands. On their way down the ship stopped at an unknown (to him)
island to let the sailors have a little R&R before heading into battle.
My father was
raised in a tiny hamlet in the Appalachian mountains of North Carolina.
This mysterious exotic island was the most beautiful place he had ever
seen. When James Michener and Rodgers & Hammerstein wrote of the South
Pacific, they touched on the experience of many GIs. But, during the war,
the southern oceans might be paradise one day and hell the next.
In midst of
his ship’s hell a forward gun turret exploded. No one ever discovered why.
His best buddy fell on top of him and my father was the only one in the
turret who survived. He was packed into a sleeping bag-type device and
cabled high over the battle to a hospital ship that brought him to Wellington,
New Zealand. He recuperated there until he could be transported to the
Naval hospital in San Diego.
Dad never told
me about his stay in New Zealand until fifty-three years later in 1996
when I told my parents about our plans to move here.
When I tell
New Zealanders this story, they understand the connection I feel. They
understand the connection between the United States and the freedom this
land experiences today. If it weren’t for the care my father received in
Wellington, I would not be here to tell the story. And New Zealand is now
home for my children and my children’s children.
|
|
|
|
Countryside
on the South Island of New Zealand
|
|
|
Don’t visit, immigrate
or retire to New Zealand thinking you will find a paradise on earth. New
Zealand is a real country with real problems. The most hopeful reality
I experience daily about New Zealand as a nation and Christchurch
as a city, is that it is big enough to have all the hells of the first
world, but small enough to be creative in attempting to solve them.
Some solutions
include cities with good access to facilities, social networks and family
for the coming “age quake,” the government urging those finishing high
school to consider trades rather than a university degree as there is a
chronic skills shortage. And, then, there is the ongoing quest for solutions
to living peacefully in this bi-cultural nation established at the ends
of the earth, at the end of the colonial era.
.
|
|
|
Celebrations
for Waitangi Day
|
|
|
Every
year, early last month, on February 6, Waitangi Day was celebrated. It
is a national holiday. Most people, it appears, think of it as a day off
from work or to go shopping for sale items. And there are some good bargains
on Waitangi Day! But, it’s really the holiday most akin to the 4th of July
in the United States. Perhaps, it is the American at work in me, but it
seems Waitangi Day should be a day of proper celebration if the country
could just figure out how or why.
The headlines
in the newspapers told us the Prime Minister, Helen Clark, was jostled
as she entered the marae (or meeting place) at Waitangi in the North Island.
The Opposition Party leader, Don Brash, who recently made a speech advocating
disregard for the Treaty saying it leads to inequity, was pelted with mud
when he tried to enter. Police, lined up to protect visitors and keep peace,
were heckled by those who felt their marae was being invaded. Ngapuhi,
the tribe whose marae is at Waitangi, has promised “Things will be different
next year.” Is there trouble in paradise?
The answer
is that living in paradise has always been about getting in and out of
trouble.
On February
6, 1840, representatives of the United Tribes of New Zealand and the Crown
of England, Queen Victoria, signed a Treaty at Waitangi in the North Island.
This Treaty basically called for an end to warring between the Crown and
Maori, the establishment of Civil Government, the granting of all the right
and privileges of British Subjects to Natives of New Zealand, AND -- this
is where it gets tricky today—their Land, Estates, Forest, Fisheries and
other properties possessed collectively or individually. That is the English
version. The problem is in the translation, of course! To the Crown these
words meant one thing, to the Maori another. The Maori word possession
is taonga and means everything that is held precious. Today what are being
fought over are the foreshores and seabeds. Maori hold these precious.
When we first
came to New Zealand, we heard something vaguely like “all the beaches belong
to the people of New Zealand. No one can buy or build on them. Everyone
has the right to walk along any beach in the country.” It sounded wonderfully
foresighted and was because of something called “The Queen’s Chain.” http://www.publicaccessnewzealand.org/files/monograph_4.html |
.....
In the 1940s
policy was developed because land and resources were being sold and movement
to preserve what was left was growing. As it turns out, beachfront property
is still being sold (often to rich Americans who in turn develop it!) and
over a third is said to be privately owned. And now a growing number of
Maori, especially those whose livelihood depends upon the sea, want their
Treaty of Waitangi rights granted. It looms as quite a problem.
.
| So,
on Waitangi Day I decided to visit the Cathedral in the Square in Christchurch.
I knew they were having a Waitangi Day service. I got there just as the
Salvation Army Band (they are always surprisingly great) had finished and
a man from the Ngai Tahu tribe, the indigenous tribe of Christchurch, welcomed
us. His greeting tried to shed some light and perspective on the current
events. He was descended, he said, from an ex-whaler and a Maori maiden.
These are the cultural roots of the native New Zealander, he said, typified
by this couple, his ancestors, as they worked together to build a family
and a nation. He acknowledged that this vision is still happening as more
and more people come from other lands to do the same. Then we heard messages
in song and speech with the same theme:
Sing two races’
different stories,
sing their
hopes and sing their needs.
Let the Treaty
write our story,
Frame our
vows and shape our deeds.
I was left
with the impression that I am a part of a young and vibrant country, still
with a vision and still willing to struggle to overcome. I can’t help but
compare this new awareness to my wee grandson, a happy little chappy, and
just eight months old on Waitangi Day! He started to crawl that week. What
that means is bumps and bruises; learning he can’t bite his mum without
getting rebuked or pull on the cat’s whiskers without getting scratched.
It means he has tough days when all those things happen and a tooth is
coming in besides. But, he is young and alive and growing, just like New
Zealand where he was born, the child of an American Jew and Gentile and
a Scottish and English Kiwi. |
|
|
|
Cathedral
at dawn in Christchurch
|
|
|
..
Because my
husband died on July 4, 2003, I have had to do a lot of thinking about
what our immigration means. Waitangi Day this year made me reflect on what
we left behind and what we have here. I am deciding that it is not about
choosing either the United States or New Zealand. It is not so much
that we immigrated to replace one country for another. Teaching English
to students from Japan, Korea, China, Thailand, Taiwan, Viet Nam, Brazil
and Germany forces me to consider the sensibilities of others who come
from nations they love as dearly as I love my birth and adopted nations.
Something bigger is happening.
..
|
|
This
is not really off the subject, but my husband, Tom, was a musician. Although
we sang together and made nine albums (this was before CDs), I am not really
a musician—in fact, my idea of having an audience is to make the people
go in another room, close the door and get busy doing things while the
sound of my playing drifts their way! Every so often, my audience can look
up and say “Hmmm…she might have gotten that chord right.” Anyway,
one of the songs I sing besides “If I Were a Carpenter” which my husband
sang to me when we were falling in love is “Blowing in the Wind.”
This something
bigger IS blowing in the wind. This blowing in the wind, for me, often
brings gracious and encouraging serendipitous events. They are often focussed
on the tension between our human desire for a paradise and confrontation
with the hellishness of reality. Here is an example.
In 2001, the
last time my mother-in-law came to New Zealand before Tom died, she wanted
to take us on a trip somewhere. Anywhere in the country, she said. She
would take whoever wanted to come, a wonderful and generous offer: she
knew that we had been working hard to become settled here and that most
everyone who came to visit had been more places than we had! We decided
to go south, about 4 hours, to Dunedin (www.cityofdunedin.co.nz).
Everyone we
met from Dunedin, including graduates of Otago University, loved the city.
The unanimous advice was, “Go when the students are there; that makes all
the difference.” But that wasn’t possible, so we enjoyed a quieter, more
subdued Dunedin. |
.
Dunedin, the
second largest city in the South Island, boasts a population of only 112,000,
in contrast to Christchurch’s 400,000. Dunedin is the Scottish city (Christchurch,
the English) and flourished during New Zealand’s Gold Rush which happened
about the same time as California’s. The city offers delightful Botanical
Gardens, wonderful examples of 19th century architecture, many hills with
panoramic views, a busy harbour, a proper winter, and a lovely peninsula
with its own Scottish castle called Larnach (www.innz.co.nz/host/l/larnach.html)
.
| Albatross
come to nest every year on the peninsula. Albatross have fascinated me
ever since I first read “The Rime of the Ancient Mariner” many, many moons
ago. Though generally not insistent upon having my own way, I let
it be known I REALLY wanted to see the albatross. For one thing, I had
learned, they mate for life. This touched me deeply as my husband’s degenerating
health made us very aware that while we had pledged ourselves to one another
for richer or poorer, in sickness and health, death might well be getting
ready to part us.
When we got
out onto the peninsula where the albatross nest (quite a fascinating and
Riviera-like drive in itself), our group of five (Tom, his mom, me, our
daughter and her friend) had to make a choice: were we going to pay $100NZ
for all of us to take a hike to a little hidden place where we could view
through binoculars the albatross nesting OR would we pay $100NZ to go on
a boat ride along the coast, view the sea life, and maybe see an albatross?
My mother-in-law (who was paying, of course) said, Let’s do the boat ride
and even if we don’t see any albatross, we will have had a boat ride and
some fresh air. Good idea, Mum.
The delightful
cruise along the coast showed off steep, rocky cliffs full of flying, squawking
smaller-than-the-albatross bird life: cormorants, shags, yellow-eyed penguins.
The rocks in the sea were covered with fur seals. But where were
the albatross? |
|
.
Our teen-aged
daughter and her friend had found a spot along the railing. I could see
them smiling and laughing, their long hair swirling around as they kept
their faces to the stiff breeze generated by the boat. I could see my mother-in-law
had also found a spot for herself. Every one on the boat had a place along
the railings. I looked around for Tom and saw him seated alone in the sun.
He was facing
the inside of the boat, relaxed, with his arms outstretched along the rail,
his face lifted to the sky. In spite of his tremendous health issues, Tom
always carried himself well; someone who didn’t know his medical history
would not have known the hell he was enduring. It seemed like it had been
one thing after another: first tachycardia, then an aortic valve replacement,
followed by high blood pressure, mild congestive heart failure, high cholesterol,
thyroid disease. Now,Type 2 diabetes was looming. A few years before, he
had lost the sight in his left eye when scar tissue developed following
a detached retina; in his right eye, a cataract was ripening that made
vision at night like being in a snowstorm. In his mid-fifties, he had to
consider giving up driving and seriously wondered if he was past his “Use
By” date.
But, this day,
because he knew he would not be able to see the wild life, he sat enjoying
the fresh air and the sunshine. This particular day, he looked unusually
content and at peace. I was drawn to a spot on the railing near a woman
who seemed to be about my age. Perhaps we would strike up a conversation
should there be an opportunity. Soon there was.
The pilot of
the boat suddenly let the engine die, got on the speaker, and told us that
if we looked to the right we would see an albatross floating on the surface
of the water. And there it was. A real, live albatross! Magnificent in
its strangeness, glorious in its hugeness, and our terrible realization
that it actually was…a bird! Of course we couldn’t tell if it was male
or female, but the pilot explained that each parent takes a turn sitting
on the nest while the other goes out to sea to feed for a week or more.
Because of
its tremendous wing-span, the albatross needs a strong air current and
a good run to take off and remain aloft. This is why, in less technological
times, the albatross was so dear to sailors: they could use the albatross
to tell which way the wind was blowing. This was the reason an albatross
was hung about the neck of its killer in the poem by Samuel Taylor Coleridge.
But, there
was no wind that day. The albatross couldn’t get back to its mate and their
nest without it. But, the albatross simply continued floating, seemingly
at peace and in unity with the rise and fall of the sea’s surface. Just
like Tom today, I thought. Both seemed to be content with what they
were, in their situations, patient to wait until the conditions were right
to lift them up above their present circumstances.
An almost holy
hush had fallen over all of us on the boat. After some minutes of staring,
I turned to the woman next to me and quietly, but excitedly, began to tell
her about my husband and what I was experiencing. “He has been so unhappy,”
I finished, “My husband is a man who has lots of talent and has always
worked hard, had energy and vision. He uses his eyes for his work. He can’t
do anything but wait for a wind to lift him up. But today he seems like
that albatross, at peace with waiting.” I was thinking of John Milton’s
poem, On His Blindness:
When I consider
how my light is spent,
Ere half my
days in this dark world and wide,
And that one
talent which is death to hide,
Lodged with
me useless, though my soul more bent
To serve therewith
my Maker, and present
My true account,
lest He returning chide:
'Doth God
exact day-labour, light denied?'
I fondly ask:
but Patience, to prevent
That murmur,
soon replies, 'God doth not need
Either man's
work or his own gifts. Who best
Bear his mild
yoke, they serve him best: his state
Is kingly:
thousands at his bidding speed,
And post o'er
land and ocean without rest;
They also
serve who only stand and wait.'
Then the woman
began to tell me her story.
“How do you
think I feel?” she said. “I am a judge from Jerusalem. I have just retired
so that I can begin to paint and write before it is too late. I want to
live the rest of my life in peace, but we have nothing but war, fighting
and unrest.”
Her family
had come from France to Israel after the Holocaust. One of her best friends
was the Ambassador from Israel to New Zealand. She had been reading New
Zealand history about the wars between the two cultures—Maori and the Crown
of England. She had read about the Treaty of Waitangi and the continually
renewed efforts to live in peace and work toward solutions. She knew that
the national anthem of New Zealand appeals to the God of Nations:
God of nations,
At thy feet,
In the bonds
of love we meet,
Hear our voices
we entreat:
God defend
our free land.
Guard Pacific's
triple star,
From the shafts
of strife and war,
Make her praises
heard afar,
God defend
New Zealand.
“I was talking
to my husband in Jerusalem last night,” she went on, “I said to him, “What
have we been doing in Israel for the last 50 years? Why aren’t we, the
Israelis and the Palestinians, able to do what they are doing here in New
Zealand?””
Then she turned
to me and said, “Like that albatross, all we can do is wait… wait for….”
She stopped--she couldn’t go on--gave a little shrug, and then lifted her
hands into the air.
Could this
little spot of earth, I have wondered since, this small nation, out in
the middle of the South Pacific serve as a place of light to the world?
The answer,
my friend, is blowing in the wind.
Note: Candy
is now making plans to take her Easter school holidays on Norfolk Island
where they celebrate the American Thanksgiving!
To contact
Candy Click Here
The following
are the two previous articles that Candy has written about New Zealand
for the magazine:
Living
In New Zealand ~ Answers
& Anecdotes Part 1
Life,
Liberty, The Pursuit Of Happiness And Dying - Reflections
On Immigration To New Zealand
.
.
|