< Disclaimer> < Return To Issue Article Index>

Although most people don’t know it, the first allegiance of all U.S. businesses is no longer to their customers.  They are first and foremost undercover agents for the U.S. government. The duty of discretion and care for customers has been supplanted by an overriding duty to conduct surveillance and notify the government of “suspicious” behavior by their customers and of large cash transactions.  This surveillance is threatening enough by itself. However, to facilitate “information exchange,” the information is made available electronically to dozens of law enforcement agencies, including state and local police. An agency does not have to suspect any crime before it accesses a report, and no court order, warrant, subpoena, or even written request is needed.  Law enforcement agencies can “troll” through this information whenever they want. This has resulted in substantial “leakage” of the data supposedly maintained “securely” by the government. There are dozens of examples where confidential information has been disclosed to third parties, including organized crime figures, private investigators and even the suspect under investigation.16 Under these circumstances, you don’t have to be trying to “hide” something to be concerned. You just have to be worried about crimes such as identity theft, the world’s fastest growing crime, which are facilitated by the proliferation of data in government databases. In just the last year, 3.3 million Americans fell victim to this crime.17  In this column, I’ll show you what types of surveillance businesses are legally obligated to perform, and teach you the steps you can take to legally bypass it. I’ll also show you how you can use these same techniques to reduce the threat of identity theft. Know the Rules for “Suspicious  Transactions” and Cash At the heart of the surveillance infrastructure are laws that require banks, brokerages, casinos, and even the U.S. Postal Service to file a “Suspicious Activity Report” (SAR) if they believe a customer might be violating any law or regulation.18 The transaction threshold for mandatory SAR filing is US$5,000, reduced to US$2,000 for money transmitters (non-banking companies such as Western Union that send or receive money on behalf of their customers).19 Don’t expect these businesses to tell you that they’ve notified the government that they think you’re suspicious—doing so is a criminal offense. The best way to avoid triggering a SAR filing is to avoid the behaviors that the Treasury Department says are suspicious. These include:  • Unusual payment methods, such as large amounts of cash, multiple or sequentially numbered money orders, traveler’s checks, cashier’s checks or payment from third parties. • Unwillingness by a customer to provide complete or accurate contact information, financial references, or business affiliations.  • Attempts by a customer to maintain a high degree of secrecy with respect to the transaction, such as a request that normal business records not be kept. • Purchases or sales that are unusual for the particular customer, or type of customer. • Purchases or sales that are not in conformity with standard industry practice.20

The Sovereign Society, headquartered in Waterford, Ireland, was founded in 1998 to provide proven legal strategies for individuals to protect their wealth and privacy, lower their taxes and to help improve their personal freedom and liberty. The Society's highly qualified contacts recommend only carefully chosen banks and investment advisors as well as financial and legal professionals located in select tax and asset haven jurisdictions around the world. The Society provides advice concerning the establishement and operation of offshore bank accounts, asset protection trusts, international business corporations (IBCs), private foundations, second citizenships and foreign residency, as well as practical safeguards for financial, Internet and personal privacy. The Sovereign Society stands alone in fulfilling this singular, international offshore service role for its members. To learn more about our organization and how you too can become a member, please click here.

Do not divide transactions over US$10,000 into smaller ones to try to avoid the reporting obligation. This is known as “structuring” and is illegal.25 Many individuals have been jailed for the crime of “structuring” cash transactions in their bank account, even when every dime of the money was legally earned, and taxes paid. 

Avoiding Surveillance in Your Bank Account

Since 1970, U.S. banks have been required to keep copies of all account transactions for at least five years. Since 1986, they have been required to notify the IRS of all interest earned in the account, and to ask for a Social Security number (SSN) when you open an account. SAR reporting began in 1988 and has become increasingly stringent. And beginning in October 2003, opening a bank account requires submitting to a rigorous “know your customer” identification process.

The disclosures you make prior to opening an account are largely unavoidable, but once you have done so, you can take several steps to lower its profile. Consider the following strategies. 
• Write personal checks only for ordinary, everyday expenses. Don’t write a personal check for any purchase that you’d rather keep private. Pay for such purchases with cash or a money order.
• Carry a minimal account balance. Larger accounts merit investigation much more often than smaller ones. 
• Never have your home address or SSN imprinted on your checks. This is an invitation to identity theft. 
• Do not engage in unusual transactions without first discussing them with a representative from the bank. Large deposits in an account with a historically low balance, large funds transfers in or out of the account or any other activity not in keeping with the historical use of your account all can lead to a SAR. Contact the bank and ask them for their recommendation as to the “best” way to handle such a transaction. This gives you an opportunity to explain the transaction, and greatly reduces the possibility it will be viewed as “suspicious.” 
• “Opt out” of information exchanges. A 1999 law requires financial services companies to give customers the option of not sharing account data with unaffiliated third parties. When you receive such “privacy notice” from your bank (or credit card, insurance or brokerage company), follow the instructions to restrict data sharing. This won’t reduce data disclosures to government, but may reduce your vulnerability to identity theft. 
Keeping Securities Transactions Private

While for many years, U.S. brokers were not subject to the full thrust of U.S cash transaction and suspicious activities reporting requirements, thanks to the USA PATRIOT Act, you can now anticipate the same type of surveillance when you open and operate a securities account as with a bank account. 

Most of the same precautions that apply to bank accounts in the preceding section also apply to securities accounts. However, I recommend one further precaution: to take delivery of your shares in physical or certificated form, rather than have a broker-dealer hold them electronically. 
This precaution makes it much more difficult for an identity thief or anyone else to use your securities account for illegal purposes. It also makes discovering the existence of the securities themselves much more difficult. The only “paper trail” that will exist for securities held in this manner will be for the original transaction and a record of any dividends paid.

The downside occurs when you want to sell your securities. You will pay extra for commissions and even more for registered mail or courier service fees, and experience delays. And if you lose the certificate, you will have to post a bond (approximately 2% of the certificate’s market value) to get it replaced.

Because it is inconvenient for the securities industry to issue share certificates, it is trying to persuade states to pass laws that would permit corporations to issue shares only in non-certificated form.26 It is probably only a matter of a few years before share certificates are only a collectors’ item. But in the meantime, they are a valuable supplement to your privacy arsenal.

Buying and Selling Precious Metals Privately

Under U.S. law, purchases of gold, silver, platinum or palladium don’t need to be reported to anyone, although the cash reporting requirements we’ve already described still apply. 

Dealers must report sales by the public to the IRS on Form 1099-B that equal or exceed minimum Commodity Futures Trading Commission approved contract sizes, as follows: 
• Gold bars. 1 kilogram (32.15 troy oz.), .995 fine or higher.
• Silver bars. 1,000 oz., .999 fine or higher.
• Platinum bars. 25 troy oz., .9995 fine or higher.
• Palladium bars. 100 troy oz., .9995 fine or higher.
• 1-oz. gold coins. Maple Leafs, Krugerrands and Mexican Onzas. 25 coins. 
• Pre-1965 silver U.S. dimes, quarters and half dollars. $1,000 face value (full bag). 
A dealer must notify the IRS if a customer appears to be deliberately “structuring” multiple sales under the reporting thresholds to avoid broker reporting. 

However, the reporting regulations apply only to “unincorporated individuals.” So, if you sell your precious metals through a business entity, no report need be filed with the IRS. You can also buy and sell precious metals without triggering these requirements by dealing with a fellow investor, either at a coin show or in a classified ad through publications such as Coin World or Numismatic News, which are available at any U.S. newsstand. 

Protecting Privacy With Collectibles

No broker reporting requirements apply to purchases or sales of collectibles: art, diamonds, antiques, stamps, rare coins, etc. Another reason collectibles are valuable as a private investment is that they do not generate current income. Nor are dealers required to notify any government authority when you sell collectibles, except for the cash transactions we’ve already discussed.

Numismatic coins. Rare or “numismatic” coins are among the most liquid collectible investments and subject to the smallest dealer mark-ups. From a privacy standpoint, uncertified coins (not pre-graded in plastic “slabs”) are preferable. If you’re new to coins, though, you’ll probably want certified coins to guard against overgrading—although some certified coins are overgraded. The Professional Coin Grading Service (www.pcgs.com) and the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (www.ngccoin.com) are the most widely accepted certification services. 
The most private way to purchase rare coins or other collectibles is at auctions, coin shows or local coin shops. Pay cash and don’t leave your name. Selling inexpensive coins in transactions under US$1,000 rarely poses a problem. Larger sales may make dealers suspicious of your motives. 

Diamonds. Diamonds are the world’s most concentrated form of wealth. They also have such a low profile that you can privately carry tens of thousands of dollars or more of value on your finger, with very few people noticing. In addition, the diamond market is highly liquid. Diamonds can also be transported quietly and legally and sold globally in most major cities. 

However, like rare coins, diamond prices fluctuate dramatically. And DeBeers (a company that has controlled the diamond market as a virtual monopoly for nearly a century) has announced that it will stop controlling the price of diamonds through manipulation of the amount of rough (uncut) diamonds on the market. With prices set by supply and demand, diamond values are likely to become even more volatile. One diamond purchasing strategy involves investing in colored diamonds, which are much more rare than white diamonds and that, unlike white diamonds, have enjoyed relatively steady price appreciation for the last 30 years. 

All diamonds should be purchased with an accompanying Gemological Institute of America (GIA) grading report or GIA origin of color report. (The GIA is the world’s pre-eminent independent gemological laboratory that issues reports on a diamond’s quality.)

Mark Nestmann is an offshore journalist and consultant and the author of many books and reports on privacy and wealth preservation. He is the Editorial Director for The Sovereign Society -
..

< Send a Letter to the Editor > < Subscribe> < Submit An Article >< Disclaimer>