Convergence Under The Bed Spread Exploring The Possibility Of A Falling Credit Rating For US Government Debt  Banana Republic Style! ~ by Dan Denning
Overseas JobsEstates WorldwideArticles For Investing OffshoreeBooks For ExpatsCountries To Move ToLiving OverseasOverseas RetirementEscape From America MagazineEmbassies Of The WorldOffshore Asset ProtectionEscapeArtist Site Map
Articles On Various Subjects Index ~
Convergence Under The Bed Spread
Exploring The Possibility Of A Falling Credit Rating For US Government Debt Banana Republic Style!
By Dan Denning
Illusions often die a sudden and not-so respectable death.

The other day on the Paris metro an overweight middle aged woman took to the center of the car and muttered under her breath repeatedly “Pere Noel est Morte.” Santa Claus is dead.

While this was not news to me (nor was it exactly true, in the sense that Santa Claus doesn’t really exist) it was quite shocking to the handful children within ear shot. A crash in the Santa index ensued.

Such is the fate of misplaced faith, which brings us to the U.S. bond market. The conventional way to measure general systemic risk in the U.S. bond market is known as the TED spread. It's the market's measure of how close we are to total financial meltdown; he much anticipated “Financial Reckoning Day”...
Search 4Escape - The International Lifestyles Search Engine
 - 4Escape is a search engine that searches our network of websites each of which shares a common theme: International relocation, living ? investing overseas, overseas jobs, embassies, maps, international real estate, asset protection, articles about how to live ? invest overseas, Caribbean properties and lifestyles, overseas retirement, offshore investments, our yacht broker portal, our house swap portal, articles on overseas employment, international vacation rentals, international vacation packages,  travel resources, every embassy in the world, maps of the world, our three very popular eZines . . . and, as they are fond to say, a great deal more.
Technically speaking, the TED spread is the difference between interest rates on the 90-day U.S. Treasury and the 90-day Eurodollar deposit contract. Eurodollars are dollar-denominated deposits held by commercial banks outside the United States and in Europe. All things being equal, when they are packaged up and sold like U.S. bonds, the issuer must pay a slightly higher interest rate than the 90-day T-bill.
The issuer pays the higher interest rate because the U.S. government collects its revenues at the barrel of a gun, and commercial banks do not. This, presumably, makes the U.S. government a "safer" credit risk, e.g. less likely to default. And so the Feds don't have to pay as high an interest rate to attract buyers. 

The TED spread measures of systemic risk. It's premised on the belief that the U.S. bond market is the financial world’s safe haven of last resort. But what, to borrow a phrase from Michael Moore, if that’s a big fat lie?

A few weeks back, Addison Wiggin and I attended a luncheon in London offered by the folks at Arbor Research. Their lead research analyst Jim Bianco gave a riveting account of derivatives risks at Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.

Offshore Resources Gallery
When Technology Fails?
When Technology Fails - A Manual for Self-Reliance, Sustainability, and Surviving the Long Emergency
The Six Best Property Buys
The Six Best International Property Buys Right Now - Where in the world could you best position yourself for profit right now? - FREE Report For Immediate Download
After Jim’s speech, I asked him over sandwiches, what I perceived to be a natural question. “What would happen if the credit quality of US government debt were to be downgraded?” citing as possible causes, the Treasury’s implied guarantee of Fannie and Freddie. [Similar themes are explored, by the way, in Antony Mueller, in his essay:

The End Of Dollar Supremacy?
http://www.dailyreckoning.com/body_headline.cfm?id=3497

It would never happen,” Bianco replied, “That would mean the end of the modern financial system.” Needless to say the Jim’s response got me thinking.

If the U.S. bond market isn’t as safe as you’ve been told, how would you know? How can you actually measure how close we are to the day of gloom and doom and $8,000 gold? 

You’d begin to have an idea that the world was going to hell in a hand-basket if you could measure the spread between U.S. debt (which WE know to be risky) and debt that the market considers risky, namely baseline emerging market debt (BED).

A BED spread, you say? Ask... and you shall receive. 

The BED spread (or BS as it’s been called by a few readers) is the proprietary indicator I developed to keep track of how close the U.S. government is to losing its reputation for credit worthiness. 

To get it, I established a spread between emerging market debt and U.S. government debt. If I’m right about the U.S. bond market losing its gold-standard reputation, the spread should converge over time. U.S. government bond yields will rise as the dollar falls. And emerging market debt yields will fall as it becomes comparatively less risky than dollar-denominated debt. 

You COULD come up with an indicator by comparing the 10-year Treasury note with, say, an equivalent Argentine or Russian government note.

Offshore Resources Gallery
Live On A Barge In Europe
Awesomely engineered aquatic routes across the countryside have been re-born; the insatiable appetite of the ‘tourist’ has led to heavy investment in canals and waterways all over Western Europe.
Dominica Passport Now
Enjoy all of the benefits that go with having a passport from a nation that respects your privacy, your dignity, and your freedom to make individual choices.
Escape From America Magazine - The Magazine To Read To If You Want To Move Overseas
- Began Summer 1998 - Now with almost a half million subscribers, out eZine is the resource that expats, and wantabe expats turn to for information.  Our archives now have thousands of articles and each month we publish another issue to a growing audience of international readers.  Over 100 people a day subscribe to our eZine.  We've been interviewed and referenced by the Wall Street Journal, CNN, The Washington Post, London Talk Show Radio, C-Span, BBC Click Online, Yahoo Magazine, the New York Times, and countless other media sources.  Featuring International Lifestyles ~ Overseas Jobs ~ Expat Resources  ~ Offshore Investments ~ Overseas Retirement - Second Passports ~ Disappearing Acts ~ Offshore eCommerce ~ Unique Travel ~ Iconoclastic Views ~ Personal Accounts ~ Views From Afar ~ Two things have ushered us into a world without borders... the end of the cold war and the advent of the world wide web of global communications ? commerce.  Ten years and over one hundred issues!  We're just getting started - Gilly Rich - Editor
But I prefer to take a broader measure of emerging market debt versus U.S. government debt. I picked two closed-end bond funds, GVT and EMD. 

GVT is the Morgan Stanley Government Income Trust. One hundred percent of the fund's assets are dollar denominated. When I first calculated the BED spread, about three weeks ago, GVTt currently yielded 4.18%. That was higher than the yield on the 10-year note at the time  (4.04%.) But GVT is an excellent proxy for the market's general perception of the creditworthiness of the U.S. government because it’s a “basket” of government bonds. Here are its top five holdings and allocations: 

1. U.S. Treasuries 30.28% 
2. Short-term bonds 27.99% 
3. Fannie Mae bonds 23.02% 
4. Freddie Mac bonds 11.96% 
5. Ginnie Mae bonds 6.75% 

To represent the other side of the spread,  emerging market debt, look at EMD, the Salomon Brothers Emerging Market bond index. Eighty-eight percent of the fund's holdings are in sovereign (government) debt. While not absolute, you’re basically comparing apples to apples…the bonds of emerging market governments versus Uncle Sam's bonds. Here is how EMD's top five holdings are allocated: 

1. Brazil 23.57% 
2. Mexico 20.87% 
3. Russia 17.97% 
4. Colombia 5.08% 
5. Ecuador 5.05% 

When I first calculated the BED spread, EMD yielded 9.76%. So about three weeks ago, the BED spread was 5.58%. Based on the wide spread, the market did NOT perceive a great deal of risk in U.S. government debt. But that would soon change…

The second time I calculated the BED spread, the yield on EMD fell to 9.59%, while GVT's yield was up to 4.22%. In bond speak, that means bond prices are up for EMD and down for DVT (yields and prices move in the opposite direction).

The new BED spread was 5.37%. Convergence approacheth. And it's precisely what you'd expect given the news in the bond market that week.  Why? 

First, Moody's Investors Service upgraded the rating on Russia's foreign-currency bonds by two levels. Russia's Eurobonds were upgraded to Baa3--the lowest investment grade level--from Ba2. Specifically,  Russia's 5% dollar bond due in 2030 gained 2.65 cents on the dollar in one day. 

That particular bond is the most traded emerging market Eurobond. And it was bound to help EMD. While 17% of the fund's total assets are in Russian debt, its single largest holding is $7.7 million worth of Russian government bonds -- about 10% of its total portfolio. 

Second, emerging market debt yields are converging with U.S. Treasury yields because what's good for Russia is turning out to be good for other emerging market bonds, including Brazil. Brazil's 8% bond due in 2014, which is THE MOST widely traded emerging market bond, rose that week too, as yields fell. Brazilian bonds constitute 23.5% of EMD's portfolio, and four of its 10 largest particular holdings. 

On the other side of the spread, the U.S. government side, there was trouble in agency security land. Agency securities are otherwise known as the mortgage-backed bonds issued by Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae. And like a dream it can't wake up from, the market is slowly recognizing how many bad credit risks Freddie and Fannie have taken...and how this directly implicates the creditworthiness of the U.S. government, whose implied guarantee of agency debt made it possible for Freddie and Fannie to get so overextended in the first place. 

The problem reared its ugly head in Atlanta and Pittsburgh a week ago. Federal Home Loan Banks in both cities reported losses of $9 million and $7 million, respectively, for the third quarter. Both banks claimed the losses came from low mortgage rates "pinching off" interest income on their derivatives holdings.

Perverse, isn't it? It's those same low interest rates that have kept mortgage issuance and refinancing activity so high. Yet even what's been historically good for the mortgage lenders is now turning out to be a problem. 

Granted, $9 million and $7 million losses won't break the bank. But the $200 million loss reported by the New York FHLB last month gets closer to breakage. THAT loss was chalked up to bad investments. And that brings us to the heart of the issue, with agency debt in particular and U.S. government debt in general. 

Freddie and Fannie have been issuing mortgage-backed debt at a ferocious pace in the era of historically low mortgage rates. It's dangerous risk-taking predicated on the ability of new homeowners to pay off mortgages AND the appetite of bond investors for mortgage backed securities. Yet that's exactly the kind of investment that went bad in New York. And that's the investment that will likely go bad all over the country. 

To keep expanding, the housing boom must attract more and more buyers. The voracious need for new buyers forces Freddie and Fannie to lend to riskier borrowers. To keep the boom going, the market extends more and more generous offers to less and less qualified buyers.

Eventually, Fannie and Freddie will be on the hook in two ways. They will have made loans to homeowners who can't pay. And they will have packages up those loans and sold them as bonds to bondholders who, will, I’m guessing, demand payment. 

Who will pay the bondholders when the homeowners default? The U.S. government? Santa Claus? The Daily Reckoning Paris office? You? 

The U.S. government ALREADY has its hands full paying its own sovereign debt not to mention Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid  GVT, which has 30% of its holdings in Treasuries and 35% in agencies -- is a great proxy for the credit problems of the U.S. government. 

We saw it again this week as the Treasury department reported a $374 billion deficit for the fiscal year ended in September. That number was better than the White House predicted back in July. But it’s not exactly good. And it wasn’t exactly good for the BED spread.

As of this writing, EMD yields 9.50% and GVT yields 4.24% for a spread of 5.26. That’s three weeks in a row of convergence…from 5.58 to 5.37 to 5.26.

The spread would be even larger if Treasuries still didn’t enjoy their reputation as safe havens. Yields on the 10-year note climbed as high as 4.46% before stocks retreated when the Conference Board reported that the leading economic indicators fell in September.

And who knows after all? I could be completely wrong. Perhaps 10-year notes wont rise much beyond 5%, if that. But I suspect otherwise. I suspect there is looming chaos in the bond market, spawned by Fannie, Freddie, and the simple belief that U.S. bonds will always be accepted as safe and dependable. 

If you believe that, I’d like to introduce you to my big fat friend in his bright red suit.

Warm regards,

Dan Denning,
for The Daily Reckoning

P.S. EMD and GVT are not perfectly representative of the yields on the underlying bonds in their respective portfolios. This is a function of how closed-end funds calculate yield. But in general, the BED spread gives you a pretty solid way to measure the big-picture perception of creditworthiness in the market. 

And it’s also an excellent indicator for when to try and make money by “selling the dollar.

Dan Denning is the managing editor of Strategic Investment. He is currently researching the calamitous effects a correction of the U.S.'s "twin deficits" would have on the economy. To learn more see Dan's report: 

http://www.agora-inc.com/reports/DRI/HungarianA/

Articles On Various Subjects Index ~

Contact  ~  Advertise With Us  ~  Send This Webpage To A Friend  ~  Report Dead Links On This PageEscape From America Magazine Index
 Asset Protection ~ International Real Estate Marketplace  ~ Find A New Country  ~  Yacht Broker - Boats Barges ? Yachts Buy ? Sell  ~  Terms Of Service
© Copyright 1996 -  EscapeArtist.com Inc.   All Rights Reserved