| In a civilized
society it is recourse to the courts. I'm sorry to say that in certain
instances in Portugal, and many another developing nation which hasn't
quite got the civilized habit, it can be the loaded gun. This can be a
little unsettling to say the least.
What all of
this amounts to is that the problems in the first section cant necessarily
be solved by your lawyer, either because he or she doesn't check some of
the problems, or because they don’t care, or because whatever the outcome
it cant be backed up in court.
So the first
big problem is getting yourself a good lawyer. You are probably better
off getting one from outside the country who is used to the norms of your
country.
Let's have
a closer look at the problems under this category.
The property
does not have planning consent as advertised (in other words it is either
built illegally, or you cant build on the land you are intending to buy).
There is a problem with connecting services. For instance, you have no
right to water, or the public water and sewerage system doesn't pass anywhere
near your property. Or you are living in a dry area, and although there
is water, it is likely to run out pretty soon, like just after you have
paid your money. Maybe the seller isn't the owner, or is only one of several
owners. Maybe the property being sold is not the same as that described
in the deeds, or there are debts registered against the property. Maybe
there are rights of way over the property, or quite simply you are buying
land, but you have no access, or it is dependant upon someone else's goodwill.
You can sort
out all these problems relatively easily, but you must realise they can
exist in the first place. You need answers to your questions about these
subjects. If someone shrugs, and says something silly like "Don’t worry
about that", or "Oh that wont be a problem", get another lawyer. Always
remember there are plenty of properties to buy, and there are other lawyers.
You don’t have to buy the house with problems, and you don’t have to use
a dodgy or lazy or incompetent lawyer.
The following
situation shows how careless some people can be about basic things.
I once had
an extremely stupid conversation with a lady who had just been widowed.
She inherited a lot of money and decided to invest in a property in Almeria,
southern Spain. When I asked her just a few simple questions, such as:
"What's the water situation like these days in Almeria?" She looked puzzled,
and answered that it came out of a tap like anywhere else.
"Yes, but do
you have rights to public water?" I persisted.
Well, maybe
she did, maybe she didn't, but her response to that question was the height
of stupidity. She said, "But the construction is being done by an American
company. They must have checked all that before putting up the houses,
mustn't they?"
I politely
said "Good luck," and left her to her own devices, vaguely remembering
the phrase "A fool and her money are soon parted." Please remember
one very simple thing. The object of a company is to make money. You can
make more money from fools than any other commodity.
But, back
to the plot.
In many countries
solicitors charge an extortionate fee for conveyancing. In the UK the average
costs end up being around £500. The last time I bought a house in
Portugal the legal fees hit over €3,000, four times what it would
have been in the UK.
Generally you
will be advised to be sure to get yourself a solicitor to deal with the
local purchase. Let me give you several reasons why this is a bad idea.
They are horrendously
expensive. Generally they have no indemnity insurance, so if they screw
up it is your money down the drain. (Never deal with a solicitor unless
they can show you their indemnity insurance, and make sure it is current.)
They will only check the documents to see if they refer to the land you
are buying and the name on them is the same as the person selling; they
don’t do anything else; which means you wont know what is likely to be
happening next door; whether there are plans afoot to put in a motorway
extension, or a main sewer through your back garden; whether there are
disputes over boundaries; whether there are footpaths across your land;
or whether the area is zoned for tourist expansion; and so on and so on.
It is often
possible to get a foreign solicitor, who is used to dealing with these
questions to do the job for you. If you can get one, do so, but check him
out first. Also, it is usually the case that all developing countries have
people who specialise in dealing with bureaucracy. You could probably do
better employing such a person and sitting down and telling them exactly
what you want them to do, and ask for a fixed price. But you need all the
items I have mentioned above thoroughly checked. And you should get copies
of the responses, and look at them.
Only proceed
when you are happy, not before. If you are not happy, now is the time to
hassle. You should always hassle before you buy rather than afterwards.
Before,
you have some leverage, afterwards, you have none.
I would strongly
suggest you get copies of the maps that go with the deeds and check them
out with what you can see on the ground. Make sure your property has a
habitation classification, and make sure there are the right number of
people on the deeds, who correspond with the people who are selling to
you; and make sure there will be no debts registered to the land.
The map with
the deeds shows various plots with numbers on. These numbers will be described
in the text. My own deeds to my home in Portugal show me owning about six
different numbered plots, and in the text each plot has a description showing
it's size and what you can do with it: it may state it is for habitation,
or for agriculture, or some other purpose. It is easy to read these descriptions
as the words are very similar to the English. If the document does not
describe one section for habitation then you cant live there, you need
to get planning consent, unless there is a separate document from the town
hall saying otherwise. Very often an owner will claim a ruin was used as
a habitation decades ago, but unless he goes down to the town hall and
swears a statement, and two witnesses swear likewise, his claims are worthless.
If he wont make this statement tell him to go to hell and take his worthless
land with him.
No local solicitor
will check for local authority plans to do any building or compulsory purchase
near your land. They wont check your boundaries or for any disputes. They
wont check your access or rights of way, or your right to access basic
services such as electricity water and drainage. Basically this is why
employing one is a total waste of time and money.
I recently
bought a house with a track running right across it. I insisted that I
would not buy unless the Camara (town hall) would confirm it was not a
public right of way. The first document I received showed it was public,
until I found that the solicitor had asked for clarification on the river!
The second letter came back showing no right of way over the land, so I
purchased. I also insisted on a letter from the camara showing footpaths.
You can actually
look at all this stuff in the town hall or at the water department. Both
have large-scale maps, and buying land without looking at these maps is
idiotic.
An interesting
aside here. I subsequently raised a mortgage on of my properties and
an illiterate Portuguese surveyor came out (called a valuer here, not a
surveyor; a surveyor draws maps). He claimed my home was in the wrong borough
and I had no right of habitation. It took me three months of argument to
prove with my crummy Portuguese that the surveyor was obviously a half-wit.
The address was given on the caderneta predial and it cross-referenced
with all the numbered plots with their descriptions, and the whole thing
dated back to 1927. So much for legal and professional competence in Portugal.
One other
point is of interest at this stage. Many people buy homes abroad in the
names of companies either registered within the country or offshore. The
rules in Portugal and Spain keep changing, but currently (mid 2006) the
rules are roughly as follows.
If you buy
using an offshore company, there are two classifications, the white list
and the black list. White list countries are the countries which have tax
arrangements with the local country; those on the black list don’t. This
means if you buy a house using a Turks and Caicos company you will
have a black listed company owning your home which will be taxed heavily.
If you use a company registered in another EU country or a country with
a reciprocal tax agreement in place then you will be okay. My house is
owned by a Malta company, my neighbour's by a UK company.
The benefit
of a company owning your home is that when you sell you don’t sell the
house, only the shares of the company. If the company is offshore there
is no corresponding sale within the country and so tax is not payable.
It also means that the purchaser does not pay purchase tax on the property.
On the other hand, there are expensive maintenance contracts for foreign
companies. Generally speaking I would suggest that under current rules
if you intended holding the property only for a short time you would be
better off owning it through a white-list company, and if you are intending
the place to be your home for the long term to own it in your own name.
Currently you
can trade your home up or down the family tree with no tax liability, which
is also a very useful situation. And, if you own your home through a foreign
company you will almost certainly find that obtaining a local mortgage
will be impossible. The mortgage on one of my Portuguese homes is through
the UK branch of a Portuguese bank, and setting that up was seriously complicated.
The final
point on my first list of problems concerns access. In Portugal you
have by law an automatic right of access to your land. If your neighbour
denies that access, you can go to court to resolve the matter. The court
might insist you come in through a different route. Maybe there is an old
road which has been covered over for years and it is a bit roundabout,
but so long as it gets you access you will be expected to use it. If there
is no other access, the court will give you right of way over your neighbour's
land. This will solve your access problems but it will not solve the problem
of an uptight neighbour. You need to think whether you want to start off
your new home with a serious argument with your next door neighbour. It
might be best to buy elsewhere, and leave the access problem to someone
else.
We seem to
have covered the first two sections that deal with solicitors. But what
about the local authority?
You will have
to cope with planning applications if you have bought a plot, and that
includes getting architectural drawings done for the building.
First, let's
look at a typical scenario for someone buying a plot of land in Portugal.
You find an
agent, you go on some inspection trips, you choose your plot, you buy it.
So far, so good. Now you need an architect to draw the plans, submit them
to the planning department, and get them passed.
The person
to get for this job is someone who knows several of the guys in the planning
department. My architect was chosen because he went to school with the
head planning guy. I assumed I would have a fair wind with any application
that had his name on the bottom. In Portugal I am aware of one planning
office which will give an okay to any application you make within reason,
so long as you part with a brown envelope containing €2,000. I assume
it is the same in every camara in the country. All you need do is get
a local person to find out who to talk to and what the going rate is,
then go and see them with your proposition, and the money.
The planning
department I deal with was hopeless. You may not believe this, but I do
have the plans to prove it. The plans were sent in and several load-bearing
pillars were in the wrong place, several lintels were too short, and there
was no front door. Have you ever heard of a house being built without a
proper door?
How did this
happen? Well, the architect hassled me to enclose the porch as it faced
north-west, which is where the cold wet winds come from. In the end I agreed,
only instead of adding a door on the open porch, he just filled in the
gap with a wall, so my front door was now completely blocked in. and the
plans were passed like that. Okay, I should have checked them, but that
was going to be the only change on the document and I have to admit it
never occurred to me that anyone would be that stupid, or that the planning
department would pass a set of plans showing no front door. But this is
Portugal. Be warned!
Until I got
my habitation license we had to get in and out of the place via the garage.
Doh! Obviously I have now fixed it.
With your
plans passed you will need a builder. Dealing with builders can be a nightmare.
Do get several opinions before choosing one, and check the one you choose
has an Alvara. This is a license allowing him to build. If he doesn't have
one any building that is put up by him will be illegal.
You will need
copious papers before you are finished, and all of them will cost you money.
Your habitation license is necessary, and without it and a copy of your
deeds and your passport you cant get water or electricity. That will cost
whatever the camara thinks fit. Mine cost €110. Someone else I know
only paid half that. I have no idea why.
For peace of
mind get someone to write you down a route-march showing all the stages
that have to be gone through before you have your dream home relatively
hassle-free. And get them to give you a rough idea how much each piece
of paper is going to cost. Then bite the bullet, and just work your way
through it.
Okay, so
you move in. You now have neighbours. Mine are relatively sweet, so
far. There is a gypsy encampment a kilometre down the road. They can be
a pain, and there have been a few arguments, but generally we get on okay.
And I think with them being at the end of the track they tend to keep other
undesirables away.
My other neighbours
are farmers and a postmen. They are quiet and generally friendly. None
speaks English, but we stutter away in various oddments of different languages
and seem to get on relatively okay. Being generally of peasant stock they
speak the language in their own special way, which means it is all rather
confusing. The latest word to stump us was "ming". This was a new one on
me, and we couldn't work out what it was until someone else worked slowly
through the sentence with us and we discovered it was the local way of
saying "domingo" which means "sunday". Life in the sticks surrounded by
peasants can be terribly hard.
Peasants can
also be cantankerous and bigoted. If you get into an argument it can end
nastily. There have been half a dozen incidents in the Algarve over the
past five years when an argument has ended with one party going for his
gun. There is no threatening behaviour. The guy comes back, takes aim,
and shoots, and that is that. He will then sit down and wait for the guardia
to come and take him away.
Dealing with
this sort of thing is difficult. The secret is to try and strike a balance
between standing your own ground and giving way a little. But talking
about inter-personal skills is beyond the scope of this article.
Generally
speaking we have found the Portuguese to be good neighbours. We know
of several incidents where there have been thefts, and the police have
been called in, but generally the accused denies all knowledge of the theft
and that is the end of the matter. On the other hand, the Portuguese are
generally very honest. I regularly leave my keys in my cars, and often
leave my wallet on the dashboard for days on end.
I was recently
travelling on the train to Lisbon. Someone came down the corridor and there
was a bag on his seat (we have to reserve seats on the express). This was
worrying. There was the bag, but no-one admitted to owning it. The person
whose seat it was took about fifteen minutes before cautiously moving it
to the next seat, and felt responsible for its safety until its owner finally
returned from the buffet car.
I guess you
have to accept that every country can be a right royal pain in the backside
unless you know how to get around, dodging the screw-ups. But if you can
successfully get around the Portuguese hassles then you will find the place
a rather pleasant home. |