|
China, New Zealand
and the Rest of the World
|
|
.
| I spent much of the
last couple of months on the road, and you should be interested in the
investment implications of the observations made below.
As for the broader markets, I’m not
going to say anything about stocks and bonds because there are very few
that are worth owning. That’s not to say 2003 wasn’t a good year to have
done so. But I believe that we’re on the edge of a disaster for bond holders.
And that 2003 was a rather inevitable (however unpredictable in timing)
bear market rally. And, since stocks are so overpriced by any conventional
measure – in addition to the fact I can see absolutely no reason to own
them – I suspect they’re headed down in the months to come. The public
may be down on the beach picking up pretty shells, now that the tide has
gone out after the storm, but they’re going to be washed away when it comes
back in.
There is an exception to this, however:
The resources issues. As I pointed out last month, all the metals have
skyrocketed – copper, nickel, molybdenum, PGMs, cobalt, you-name-it. The
only relative laggards have been oil and the precious metals. No problem.
Their stocks went through the roof last year. But, despite that (because
I generally prefer selling after huge run-ups) I believe things are going
to be much better this year. We’ve exited the “easy money” first stage
of the Great Resources Bull Market, and we’re into the tougher “wall of
worry” second stage. I’m holding on for the “manic bubble” third stage,
which is many months down the road.
In recognition of these things, I
spent a week at two mining conventions just before this went to press.
I’ll discuss all the companies I visited with in the March issue, which
I believe you’ll find quite interesting.. |
| The Author Douglas Casey
graduated
from Georgetown University in 1968, where he was a classmate of Bill Clinton.
He's probably best known for his books: The International Man (Alexandria
House, 1976) sold over 50,000 copies in the US, and became the best - selling
book of all time in what was then Rhodesia. Crisis Investing (Harper &
Row, 1979) became the largest selling financial book in history, sitting
at #1 on the New York Times bestseller list for 29 weeks. It accurately
forecast the boom in precious metals, and the high interest rates of subsequent
years. Strategic Investing (Simon&Shuster, 1982) received the
largest advance ever for a financial book. It accurately forecast the 1980's
stock market boom, and lower precious metals prices. On the New Yok Times
bestseller list for 7 weeks. |
|
|
|
|
.
China
I’ve spent a fair amount of time
in China over the years, not even counting living in Hong Kong. There’s
no question in my mind the 21st Century will belong to China, much as the
20th did to America. Europe will mainly serve as a source of houseboys
and maids for the Chinese. But, try as I might, I can’t see a safe direct
way to take advantage of this megatrend at the moment.
It’s widely touted in the press that
the Chinese yuan is an undervalued currency. That’s become accepted as
an article of faith by everyone from government officials to financial
advisers. I’m not so sure when I look at property prices in Beijing and
Shanghai. Further, the reported money supply has been increasing over 20%
per year. It might work out, but holding yuan in hopes of an upvaluation
impresses me as a mediocre bet. Certainly if you hold them in a Chinese
bank, most of which are insolvent. S&P reports that about 45% of Chinese
bank loans, equaling about $850 billion, are non-performing. That’s why
the Chinese government recently injected something like $45 billion to
shore up two big banks.
The Chinese government reports $403
billion of foreign exchange reserves at the end of 2003, net of the $45
billion they used in the bank bailout. That’s a rise of $117 billion from
the end of 2002. It’s unclear in exactly what form that money is held,
but the vast majority is undoubtedly US dollars. Supposedly, they’ve been
selling yuan to buy dollars (in the form of US Treasury securities) in
order to enhance their exports. Maybe. After all, the US appears to have
a bottomless appetite for both foreign capital and foreign goods. But if
I was a Chinese central banker, I’d feel pretty stupid holding all those
floating abstractions, in that they’ve lost about one third of their value
against stronger currencies in the last couple of years. And I’d want to
replace the paper with gold.
How about buying Chinese stocks?
I don’t think it makes any sense. The huge amount of bad bank debt, combined
with government bailouts, a rapidly expanding money supply, and an absolutely
frenetic building boom has got to have created gigantic distortions in
the country’s economy. You have no way of knowing how all that could affect
any given company. But it’s not likely to be good.
.
|
Carry out family planning,
implement the basic national policy - - Circa 1986
|
|
|
|
|
I’m not trying to be negative about
something most people seem to think is a “sure thing” just for the sake
of being contrary. Although the fact everybody likes something as an investment
is reason enough to be contrary. I’m a huge China bull. But the time to
buy is during a crisis, not what’s likely the peak of a boom. And when
you do buy, what you’ll want are small entrepreneurially run companies,
not doddering behemoths that were spun off by the State, overloaded with
self-dealing, concrete-bound managers and zillions of extra employees.
And that describes most public Chinese companies. The Chinese press has
recently reported that, in the first half of 2003, 8,000 communist Party
members fled abroad, 6,500 are listed as missing, and another 1,200 committed
suicide. Even with 65 million Party members, these are anomalous numbers.
The speculation is that many of them were afraid of being caught in corruption.
In any event, my approach is not
to diversify broadly, but to concentrate force in what seems to be the
best place to be. And that continues to be precious metals and mining stocks. |
.
Europe
Whenever I visit heavily taxed, heavily
regulated, bureaucratic, welfare-ridden, philosophically socialist Europe
I’m forced to ask myself how it’s able to do as well as it does. One would
expect to see a gradually declining standard of living, but to all appearances,
the place seems to be doing fine. Even if it’s not booming the way the
Orient is.
The reason, I suspect, is that while
taxes throughout most of Europe are outrageous, very few people feel a
moral obligation to pay them. And they don’t pay them; if they think there’s
any possible way of dodging them, they do. The use of offshore companies
and bank accounts is widespread. Actually, that’s the case almost everywhere
in the world except the US and, to a lesser degree, the other Anglophone
countries.
As for regulations, Europeans have
many more, but they feel no moral imperative to obey them. And, although
the average European may be a socialist, he’s also enough of a cynic to
save as much of his paycheck as he can, unlike most Americans.
Those things, plus centuries of accumulated
capital (hence Milton Friedman’s famous dictum “There’s a lot of ruin in
a country”) are the factors holding the place together.
But with the EU coming down hard
on traditional tax havens, and severely compromising bank secrecy within
Europe, it’s going to become much harder and more expensive to evade taxes.
And that’s going to erode the continent’s capital base. Further, European
Central Banks have been aggressive sellers of gold over the years, and
now the Euro is “backed” mostly by the US dollar. That’s eventually going
to be a big problem for savers.
I continue to be a big fan of the
Orient, where people culturally have most of the European’s virtues, and
still few of their vices.
.
New Zealand
Longtime readers know I’ve been a
fan of New Zealand for years, both as a place to invest and a place to
spend time. The place is still as beautiful and friendly as ever, but some
of my enthusiasm is waning. As those of you who acted on my previous advice
have found, the Kiwi dollar has risen from a low of US$0.39 to a recent
high of almost $0.70 – about a 75% gain. Which means that, for Americans
anyway, everything here is now about 75% more expensive. Plus, property
values, at least in desirable locations like Queenstown and farms on the
ocean, are up at least 50%. The good news is that those who took the plunge
here are up well over 100% in a couple of years.
I think the New Zealand dollar can
go higher for several reasons. One is that, despite its huge increase,
prices here are still cheap by American standards; they’re just not free
anymore. Another is that this is a commodity-driven economy, and the bull
market in commodities has really just gotten started. A third is that,
notwithstanding bear market rallies, the US dollar itself is in serious
trouble. |
|
Motueka Valley, New Zealand
|
|
It is often said that location
is everything...
|
|
|
|
|
|
.
I also think property prices here
can go higher. It’s going to continue to draw well-to-do Americans and
Europeans looking for a safe, mellow place for at least a second home;
the world’s political situation promises to become uglier and more dangerous
in the years to come. Furthermore, the place is increasingly a magnet for
opportunity-seekers from the Orient. New Zealand will do just fine, and
I still urge you to get on a plane and take a look – especially during
the northern hemisphere winter, when the climate down here is a delight.
One thing about New Zealand is that
it’s testimony to how progress can and will be made in spite of the best
efforts of government to subvert it. New Zealand has been burdened with
one loopy socialist government after another practically forever. Including
the present one. But it’s still a nice place to be. One can only conjecture
how much better it would be if Wellington wasn’t populated by wingnuts
dedicated to dissipating their countrymen’s capital. In places like Niue,
for instance.
Niue
An excellent example is offered by
Niue (not to be confused with Nauru, or Norfolk Island), a 260 sqaure kilometer
island nation north of New Zealand. The place has been independent since
1974, but relies basically 100% on welfare from New Zealand. The 1,500
residents are supposed to have a GDP of about NZ$14 million, but all that
proves is how unreliable, even ridiculous, such figures can be. They produce
nothing but some coconuts and taro, and two-thirds of the 500 people who
are employed are on the government payroll. Everybody knows it’s just an
embarrassing scam; New Zealand pays these people NZ$7.5 million a year
to pointlessly shuffle papers..
.
| I know a number of Niue
people, and have been tempted to go to there. And not just because it’s
a quite beautiful coral atoll, unusual in that it’s raised, on average,
about 40 meters above sealevel. If I wanted a beach/diving vacation, I’d
go back to Thailand. Tiny countries like this tend to overlook their most
valuable asset: their national sovereignty. There’s a real need for another
Hong Kong, and with the proper legal and economic environment, Niue could
become one. What put me off was that there’s only one flight in to the
place each week. And, as far as getting the natives excited about making
their country a beacon of freedom and prosperity for the world… let’s admit
it, it’s easier to just collect the dole. I’ve been through the drill in
a half-dozen other countries, and will likely entertain the idea again
only if I’m desperately in need of amusement. |
|
\.
|
I suspect it would be a great
place for a resort
|
|
|
|
|
But Niue could be worth a trip not
for either hedonistic or altruistic, but mercenary reasons. On January
6, the place was totally devastated by Cyclone Heta, whose 200 m.p.h. winds
destroyed practically every building on the island. At this point, most
of the remaining residents are thinking of moving to New Zealand (which
is already home to an astounding 20,000 Niueans). I suspect property prices
were already low, considering what a big island it is, but land is probably
close to free now. I suspect it would be a great place for a resort except,
knowing the work ethic of Pacific islanders, you’d have to import all the
staff from the Orient. And regulations would probably make that impossible.
It was funny reading accounts in
the paper of comments by locals. Almost everybody seems to feel the New
Zealanders have an obligation to rebuild the island for them, including
their personal homes. And keep the money flowing at current levels, even
if most everybody goes to the mainland to collect their dole. |
.
…and Thailand
So we’ve written off China for the
time being. But the Orient is still the best place to be for almost everything.
It’s a big place, however, so we’ll have to narrow it down a bit. Especially
since, even though it needs a library and a lifetime of experience to understand,
we only have a few paragraphs.
My first choice for high potential,
as longtime readers will recall, has been Burma. It’s very cheap, very
beautiful, lightly populated, and right next door to Thailand. The ruling
generals, who make it a political pariah now, will be gone at some point.
But, in the meantime, a clever entrepreneur can make deals with them, because
they all want to feather their nests. Property here will go up 10 or 20
times over the next generation. Want to make millions while having fun?
Go to Rangoon.
I like Laos, a fairly large country
of only four million, but it’s as sleepy as can be. And I can’t put my
finger on what will finally, or ever, light a fire under the place. I haven’t
been to Cambodia, but a close friend who’s lived in Hong Kong most of his
life has convinced me it’s actually the place to be. It has a coastline,
and land prices are very low. It’s still in recovery from losing a quarter
of its population under Pol Pot, and gets almost no tourism, except for
visitors to Ankor Wat. I’ll relate the full story to you when I next get
back to Southeast Asia.
.
| I recognize that few
will take advantage of these tips; perhaps they’re too exotic. But most
good investments are off the beaten path, and a little hard to get into.
And often a little scary. Of course. It’s once they’re popular, and most
of their potential has already been realized, that, perversely, they carry
serious risk .
Which leads me to Thailand. Thailand,
where I spent almost three weeks over the Christmas holidays, has always
been my favorite country in the Orient as a lifestyle choice. It’s an excellent
choice for the holidays, as well, if only because you’re likely to be bedeviled
with sappy Christmas carols only on December 25th itself. Santa Claus,
like McDonald’s and Coca-Cola, can be found in every nook and cranny of
the world. |
|
Thailand Must Be Seen To
Be Appreciated
|
|
|
|
|
.
As an investment, beachfront land
here has been a standout, going up about ten times in the last decade alone.
It’s not absolutely cheap any more; an acre of beachfront on Koh Samui
will run about $200,000, minimum. Of course, that’s still cheap relative
to what you pay in Hawaii, or Florida, or California. And it’s far more
desirable, in my opinion. You’ll find the costs of food, construction,
and servants are a tiny fraction of what they would be in the States. And
although you can easily get absolutely anything you want, the lifestyle
is far more laid back. One reason it’s so friendly is that it was the only
country in this part of the world that was never colonized.
Thailand is actually the safest and
surest way to play the boom in China, as well. As the Chinese middle class
grows, they’ll travel. And they’ll pile into Thailand, as a first choice
foreign destination, simply because it’s such a delightful place. The price
of land is going to go much higher.
.
|
|
Thailand is actually the
safest and surest way to play the boom in China
|
.
Of course things can go wrong for
a while; timing is important. The main downside to Thailand is its government,
under Prime Minister Thaksin. It’s currently a popular regime but, for
reasons I’ll describe shortly, there’s serious trouble brewing. Thaksin
used to be a general in the (notoriously corrupt) Thai police; to have
risen to that height, you’ve got to presume Thaksin excelled at corruption.
He also has an unfortunate authoritarian streak, reminiscent of Singapore’s
Lee Kwan Yu and Malaysia’s Mahattir. Which partially accounts for a rather
astounding 2,500 supposed drug dealers being killed in gun battles with
police over the last year. And insane new rules forcing bars to close at
1AM and soon, the rumor is, at midnight. Thailand is, in case you didn’t
know, the party capital of the Orient.
He thinks the Thais are too undisciplined;
in fact he thinks everything is too undisciplined. So he’s trying to organize
new international cartels for sugar, rubber, and rice; cartels always end
in disaster. Among other stupid economic ideas are the building of a $35
billion canal across the peninsula, lots of easy credit for both business
and consumers, price controls, cash giveaways averaging $23,000 each to
70,000 local hamlets, subsidized home loans, and allowing debtors to put
off loan repayments.
,
More
Articles By Doug
|
Doug
Is An Avid Polo Player
|
|
|
Visit
Doug's website for subscription information
|
Casey
Research Website
|
|
|
What this megalomaniacal
nincompoop is doing is creating a credit-driven boom, and it’s going to
result in a bust. Most Thai companies are highly leveraged, so it’s welcomed
by everyone, right now, prominently including Thai investors. All the world’s
stock markets, which tend to move together, went up substantially last
year – mostly, I believe, as a reaction to having gone down three years.
But there’s no good reason for the Thai stock market to have gone up about
100% last year (making it the world’s best performing) other than a booming
money supply.
Fortunately, Thai culture will outlast
Thaksin, the boom, and the coming bust. And the country remains perhaps
my top choice as a place to both vacation and to have a crib in the Orient.
But I’d hold off major investments until the bust. Which I expect will
come within a couple years.
Here’s a travel tip. The best hotel
in the world, for my money, is the Peninsula in Bangkok. It’s much classier,
and half the price, of the Oriental across the river, which has been unjustly
rated as the best for years. In Koh Samui, don’t even think of staying
at the outrageously overpriced Meridian; stay at the excellent, and conveniently
located, Nordic Inn, for US$50 a night.
This article originally appeared
in the February 2004 edition of Doug Casey’s International Speculator,
and is used here with permission from Casey Research, LLC, 166 South Main
St., Suite 2b, Stowe VT 05672.
Visit www.caseyresearch.com
for information on subscribing to the International Speculator, or the
Casey Investment Alert - Doug's premium service for the most serious of
investors. |
.
|