Without
question, China has quickly become the new economic growth frontier.
Pursuing investment opportunities in China have become far easier as a
result of recent changes in China’s law. Until just three years ago,
China did not have an enabling law for the formation and availability of
venture capital funds. Without such a law, substantial capital from
China's private sector could not be effectively channeled into development
of a high-tech sector for venture funding.
Since the early 1990s, Chinese government
leaders have witnessed and admired the growth of the technology sector
and the ensuing benefits to the United States’ economy. They have
attributed such growth, among other factors, to the presence of an active
venture capital community in the US and other western countries. They have
openly made known their desire to see the success of the western venture
capital process replicated in China and have taken initiatives and adopted
policies over the recent years to achieve this ambition.
In the last decade or so, a number
of US and other foreign venture capital firms made investments in Chinese
start-ups through the use of off shore funding vehicles.
According to statistics compiled
by the Asian Venture Capital Journal, the pool of venture capital dedicated
to China, including both domestic and foreign funds, stood at $3.7 USD
billion at the end of 2000. This off shore entity system approach
has been cumbersome, costly to deploy and, as a result, has only been applied
to large, late stage venture investments.
New legislative regulations recently
passed in Shenzhen, one of the most progressive cities bordering Hong Kong,
served to approve equity-based venture capital investments for startup
companies. Shortly after the Shenzhen regulation was passed, Beijing
and Shanghai quickly followed suit with similar legislation.
The document entitled 'Shenzhen tentative
regulations governing venture capital - focusing on high and new technology'
was approved in the Shenzhen Economic Special Zone and passed the governing
body and was enacted into law. It is also known as The Provisional
Regulation on Investment Trust Fund of Shenzhen. The passing of this law
created the much needed catalyst for venture capital funding and innovation.
The
passing of Shenzhen’s legislation represents a key facet of the gradual
emergence of a new capitalist framework in China.
The opportunity for foreign venture
capital firms to form joint venture operations with Chinese players under
these new rules are especially enticing given China’s financial appetite
and vast market opportunity.
Such a joint venture arrangement
allows each party to build on the other party's particular strength, with
the Chinese party sourcing deals and the foreign party providing expertise
in venture development and management.
Another advantage of funds structured
under the new Chinese law, as opposed to those structured in a jurisdiction
such as the Cayman Islands, is that they are allowed to invest directly
in local startups without the need to form a new entity, be it a joint
venture or a wholly foreign-owned enterprise (WFOE).
This flexibility is particularly
helpful in early-stage investments where high transaction costs associated
with forming a joint venture or WFOE often seem unjustified.
China is the third largest country
in the world, next to Canada and Russia; it has an area of 9.6 million
square kilometers, or one-fifteenth of the world's land mass and a growing
population of 1.3 billion people and a GDP of $980.6 billion USD.
Much
of China’s infrastructure is still being developed and the trend is to
adopt leading technologies in an effort to provide the most advanced and
productive services to this growing population. This represents a significant
global economy and market size opportunity for a venture capital business.
According to the Asian Private Equity
Review, $10 billion in investment capital went into the region in 2006,
a 74 percent compounded increase since 2000. After Japan (which,
as the world’s second largest economy, is typically considered a region
unto itself), mainland China was the top destination for new investment.
Much of the current wave of Chinese
entrepreneurial drive is attributable to US educated entrepreneurs flowing
out of hot markets such as New York, Los Angeles, Silicon Valley and back
into China.
Tens of thousands of Chinese students
learned advanced computer programming skills in the US during the 1990s
with a large majority returning to China eager to apply their skills.
A number of entrepreneurs earned substantial amounts of money working on
Wall Street or in the high-tech sector during the dot com boom and are
well prepared to duplicate their successes in China.
Given China’s economy the purchasing
power of the US dollar converts to the Chinese yuan at about 10 times the
purchasing power in China. With this seed money, returning entrepreneurs
can start whatever type of company they'd like, and China is welcoming
them back.
These
Chinese entrepreneurs are not solely impassioned by money. Patriotism
is a key motivator. The costs of living are considerably lower than
in the west. The Chinese deeply believe that China will lead the
world in the 21st century.
This deep personal drive and ambition
to assist China in that ascension is pulling these entrepreneurially driven
businessmen back to China. The investor community is fairly large
and receptive to community oriented investments.
Major corporations and the government
have available funds, but lack of investment vehicles (seed investors,
venture capital firms) needed to facilitate capital for high-tech startups
were preventing this from occurring. China never got onboard the
venture capital funded dot-com days of the high-tech boom. Historically,
Chinese venture capitalists do not have a track record of funding companies
based solely on ideas.
Although China's financial markets
have been in existent for more than ten years, Chinese startups and businesses
are still highly dependent on bank loans as their main source of financing
and capital.
As the Chinese economy becomes more
market-driven, the demand for a more efficient securities market to channel
savings to investments increases. An efficient financial market is
a requirement for venture capital investing as it provides liquidity of
the investment through public offerings of venture capital portfolio companies.
The public market liquidity allows the return of investor’s capital.
The development of China's securities
market is also important for the privatization of China's inefficient state-owned
enterprises. Furthermore, an efficient securities market will help
reform China's pension and social security systems.
The
stock market is expected to receive new capital inflows from pension funds
and the insurance industry. Currently, pension funds are not allowed
to invest in stocks. This is likely to change given the current trend.
Insurance companies have received permission to invest increasing shares
of their assets in stocks through investment funds.
Pension funds are also expected to
enter the stock market through investment funds which will provide venture
capital funds with capital to invest.
Seed and angel stage investment capital
within China is a rare find. There are virtually no seed or early
stage venture capital investors for these budding entrepreneurs.
Fully developed products, actual sales, and customers, all the things that
didn't matter in the US during the dot com boom years, matter a lot in
China. But, once these operating criteria are established, a large
pool of private equity expansion money exists, thus creating a well timed
entry into this market.
There are now several Venture Capital
rivals operating in this emerging market, each deploying their own strategy
and investment focus. They include ChinaVest, AsiaTech, DragonTech,
Beijing Venture Capital and numerous others focusing on electronics, semiconductor,
real estate, telecommunications, medical devices, biosciences, but only
a few in Software, and none focused exclusively on Software investments.
Under
like, similar conditions, about 50%-60% companies involved in venture investment
in the US make no profits, whereas in China, 70% of the companies report
excellent performance with return ratios hitting 35%, higher than the average
level in other countries.
One of the world's largest companies
specializing in high-tech services, IDG, entered China's venture investment
sector in 1990 and has made a total investment of nearly US$ 200 million.
China’s Ministry of Science and Technology recently signed a cooperation
agreement with IDG. Under this partnership, IDG will inject $1 billion
USD in China's hi-tech economy to boost the development of China's high
tech sector, per Alternative Assets.
The Ministry of Science and Technology
will provide some benefits to those invested companies by way of government
projects. China has been exploring the concept and practice of venture
capital for more than a decade and it seems that the country is now convinced
that venture capital is something to be promoted in order to stimulate
the economy while generating personal wealth.
The heightened level of innovation
and technology start-ups requiring funding in China has increased dramatically
over the last two to three years.
Culturally, trust is more important
than money in China. It's been said that the key to doing business
successfully in China depends on a person's "guanxi," a Chinese word for
trust, coupled with connections. Knowing the right people, or the
right person to introduce you to the right people, is a key attribute of
success. The software only venture capitalist, armed with industry
knowledge and his network of connections, makes for the ideal guanxi partner.
The
venture capital industry requires an ecosystem of follow-on capital resources,
including late stage, expansion capital investors. These are generally
profiled as larger, general purpose, private equity investment funds who
seek follow-on financing participation primarily from venture capital firms.
The existence of these larger investment funds diminish the venture capital
risk by providing a readily available next funding stage market
Coinciding with the introduction
of Shenzhen’s venture capital law, China's fund management industry was
also opened to foreign investment in 2002 via the World Trade Organization
(WTO). According to the US-China WTO agreement, foreign companies
are now allowed to participate through joint-ventures. Foreign companies
are allowed to take a one third stake in joint-ventures which can be increased
to 49% three years thereafter.
As a result, many foreign investment
firms have announced their intended participation in China's private equity
fund industry. This would generally be accomplished via relationships
with venture capital firms, who “feed” startup investment opportunities
to investment firms for follow-on expansion capital, thus creating a “Value
Net” opportunity.
Experienced Venture Capitalists tend
to provide much needed structure, key management, strategic advice and
operating experience to insure formidable growth company pool for investment
banks. US venture capital firms frequently work with larger investment
banks for late stage, expansion capital funding. The late stage companies
have lower risk and higher probability as an initial public offering (IPO)
candidate, as they are better poised for sustainable profitable operation
much as Salesforce.com’s (NYSE:CRM) successful Asian entry.
As US venture capital firms are becoming
increasingly interested in China’s long term promise, the challenge of
operating in the unfamiliar and often unpredictable Chinese environment
remains daunting, especially for newcomers. The visionary early stage
venture capitalists may want to take the first mover advantage now, rather
than waiting for longer term history and results. After all, venture
capital is all about risk taking and ceasing opportunities.
The country’s highly skilled and
motivated computer software work force is readily available in the key
areas of Shanghai, Beijing and Shenzhen. The overall employee payroll
costs are attractive. There are dozens of innovative technology ideas emerging,
along with highly driven, western oriented entrepreneurs. There are significant
large investment funds already established in China with several others
entering. These larger funds add to the positive entry prospects
and serve as Buyers. The emergence of a stronger stock exchange market
through recent legislative changes, i.e., allowing insurance and pension
funds to invest in stocks is highly beneficial to venture investing.
Venture capital deployed on the emerging
China software market based in Shanghai, Beijing or Shenzhen will provide
excellent opportunities to invest and develop startups into significant,
high value companies, while providing exceptionally strong investor returns.
The good news for all China investors
is that there are now more than 123 million Internet users and they are
well poised to surpass the US over the next two years.